511+ Rental Villas and Private Getaways in Fire Island |
  1. USA
  2. New York
  3. Fire Island

Fire Island Villa Rentals

About Fire Island Vacation Rentals

There are more than 511 incredible getaway rentals that are available in Fire Island. These choices include villas, hotels, and other rental options. Browse from a massive selection of luxury amenities at great prices, providing you with the dream spot to base your next vacation. Relax with BedroomVillas and uncover great stays in Fire Island.

BedroomVillas features numerous last-minute deals on villas, hotels, and rentals, in locations near you or across the globe. If you need a place for a group or event, be it a hotel or vacation rental (as well as cabins and private luxury villas), let us help. With BedroomVillas in Fire Island, you can compare options from multiple suppliers with a single click to find the price point, amenities, and style of stay that works for you. Group deals, private pools, hot tubs, allows pets, or even huge master suite bedrooms with open-air showers? You can find it all with the BedroomVillas vacation rentals, resorts, and Airbnb-style properties in Fire Island. Places to stay near Fire Island are 699.47 ft² on average, with prices averaging US $1,140 a night.

BedroomVillas helps you find the ideal holiday rental to create lifetime travel memories in Fire Island. Prices listed are often found to be discounted versus the rack rates. Just search for your destination and secure your perfect place to stay today.

Show more
Show less

Top Private Villas, Resorts, and Rentals in Fire Island

Type Count
Vacation Homes 439
Holiday Apartments 20
Cottages 16
Villas 3
Unique Vacation Rentals 1
Others 1

Use these Quick Filters to Find a Vacation Rental in Fire Island

★ Pro Tip: BedroomVillas is a luxury vacation rental website, pulling some of the top private villas and exclusive holiday stays from sources across the web. We supply you with a huge list of incredible beach houses and holiday rentals from trusted, reliable suppliers, helping you to compare prices and locations to find the best fit for your getaway. Create lifelong memories in Fire Island with BedroomVillas.

Weather in Fire Island, NY

View the weather forecast for Fire Island before booking your Fire Island Vacation Rentals to confirm your best time to go.

December - February
High 60°F       Low 26°F
March - May
High 77°F       Low 40°F
June - August
High 91°F       Low 64°F
September - November
High 84°F       Low 38°F

Stay Near Fire Island's Top Attractions

A Large Selection of Villas and Vacation Rentals from Around the World Fire Island's Research Top Attractions For Your Vacation


TWA Flight 800 International Memorial
Robert Moses Beach
Ocean Beach
Robert Moses Water Tower
Smith Point County Park
Fire Island Lighthouse
Robert Moses State Park
Sunken Forest
Ho-Hum Beach
Sailors' Haven
Lighthouse Beach
Cedar Overlook Beach
Stony Brook University
Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum
Long Beach
Port Jefferson
Roosevelt Field Mall
Splish Splash Water Park
Paramount Theater

Find Hotels, Resorts, and Rentals Nearby in these Cities & Neighborhoods


Fair Harbor 358 Properties
Atlantique 358 Properties
Lonelyville 358 Properties
Seaview 350 Properties
Ocean Beach 237 Properties
Kismet 226 Properties
Cherry Grove 209 Properties
Ocean Bay Park 102 Properties
Water Island 83 Properties
Fire Island Pines 57 Properties
Davis Park 41 Properties
Bayberry Dunes 28 Properties

Complexes around Fire Island, NY


Ocean Beach 23 Properties
Fire Island Beach 22 Properties
Ocean Bay Park 17 Properties
The Beach 4 Properties
The Pines 4 Properties
Cherry Grove 3 Properties
Beach Davis Park Fire Island 2 Properties
Bungalow 2 Properties

Frequently Asked Questions About Fire Island?

What are the top hotels or resorts in Fire Island?

We provide an array of great vacation destinations in Fire Island. If you are looking to stay in or around the Fire Island area, make sure to browse our options to find a premium rental location in a top vacation destination. Whether it is a few nights, a week, or more, we've got the luxury stays that rank among the Top Vacation Rentals in Fire Island:

How many vacation rentals have private pools in Fire Island?

We have 57 luxury villas and vacation rentals featuriung a private pool in and near Fire Island. Some of the best destinations to stay that feature or have access to a swimming pool are:

Which hotel or resort in Fire Island is best for families?

Searching for a family-friendly getaway in Fire Island? We've got you covered. Check out one of these luxurious getaways that are highly-rated and perfect fits for families of all sizes.

How many hotels, resorts, or rentals are available in Fire Island?

BedroomVillas offers a consistent supply of new options, combined with established great stays in top areas. Currently, the number of properties listed by BedroomVillas in 2025 is over 511 in the Fire Island area, and that number rises every day. By combining listings from multiple websites and travel providers, BedroomVillas can provide you with a diverse amount of choices of the best luxury stays in Fire Island. 


People Also Ask

There are 25 hotels in Fire Island and 462 rentals

Recently Booked Hotels, Resorts, or Rentals in Fire Island