Shelter Island Resorts & All Inclusive Resorts

Discover the 4 Best Resorts in Shelter Island

About Shelter Island Resorts on BedroomVillas

Looking for luxury resort stays? We've got plenty of options with an array of resorts featured on BedroomVillas. These include many resorts in or near Shelter Island. Staying in a resort or resort hotel is a great way to unwind and kick back. Gain access to more than 4 resorts near Shelter Island to have an incredible stay in your ideal destination.

There are numerous premium resorts in the Shelter Island area, many with gyms, wifi, spas, private pools & pet-friendly rooms. From wilderness resorts to oceanfront and private getaways, staying in one of these stays creates lasting memories for all kinds of travelers. Whether you're looking for a honeymoon resort for newly-married couples, a wedding resort for a destination wedding to be remembered, a golf resort for golf lovers, or resorts that are perfect for conferences and business meetings, we've got a host of options perfect for you.

All inclusive Shelter Island resorts may also be available for couples, families, or groups and for both short & long-term travelers. These resorts come with top amenities such as spas, hot tubs, pools, TVs, bars, fine and casual dining, gardens, and children's entertainment areas. Find your ideal stay and Relax with BedroomVillas.

Show more
Show less

Frequently Asked Questions About Shelter Island Resorts

There are a lot of options in Shelter Island. If you plan on staying in the Shelter Island area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the top Resort Rentals in Shelter Island:

Most of our listed resorts are suitable for families in Shelter Island. Filter your all-inclusive resorts Shelter Island with a family-friendly option to see which ones are right for you.
Yes, there are more than 4 resorts in Shelter Island that have indoor and private swimming pools. Check out our filter option and find your best resort near Shelter Island.
At BedroomVillas, the rate for luxury resorts in Shelter Island per night starts from $61. Our partner provides these prices & we calculated the average daily rate in Shelter Island. Please see our partner's price for more details.
Yes. We have all-inclusive resorts in Shelter Island that allow pets. Some of the top pet-friendly resorts in Shelter Island are:

You can see all pet-friendly places to stayin Shelter Island on BedroomVillas

Most of the resorts are perfect for travelers, but based on guest reviews in 2025, the best resorts in or near Shelter Island are:
Some of the resorts in Shelter Island have been described as romantic by other travelers: